Psychiatric Advance Directives
August 9, 2007
Just developing in the areas of disability law and estate planning is the Psychiatric Advance Directive, essentially a variant of the advance medical directive or living will that provides specific guidance for the provision of psychiatric services in the event of a person’s disability. I believe that these directives can be an effective tool for folks who have an episodic or chronic psychiatric disorder where a specific treatment with a particular provider has proven effective in returning them to normal functioning. Instructions for the gatekeepers, if you will, the directive has the potential to insure quick access to the most effective treatment.
The PAD, however, also has the potential to complicate or thwart rational treatment decision making. I can envision circumstances where an episodically ill person preparing a PAD during a period when their illness is in remission, might give instructions that limit or prohibit treatments that while previously effective in returning them to their baseline functioning, were unpleasant or distasteful, or names an authorized individual to make treatment decisions that does not agree with the opinions of family or treatment providers.
That, of course, goes to the central controversy in mental health treatment, who makes the decisions and how the interests of the individual are to be protected. Although Virginia makes mention of the PAD in its Involuntary Civil Commitment forms, there is as yet no statutory provision recognizing the directives. It will be interesting to observe how the treatment/civil liberties balance is achieved!